Our stay at Carrie and JD's was great. The house looks just like the photos and there was plenty of room for our group of 14 (which includes three kids and an infant). Being so close to the lake was wonderful (2 minute drive), and it was really nice to be able to hang out outside or in the basement while our youngest (5 months) could sleep in peace upstairs.
Many of the reviews say how well equipped the house was - I would definitely agree if you are not doing a lot of cooking, but if you are cooking every night, it's missing a few basic things like dish towels, potholders, napkins, etc. Also want to note that the house only comes with one bath towel per person and no towels for the lake or hot tub, so be sure to bring your own!